Ethnic Identity
Comparison review on “Cuban cabildos, cultural politics, and cultivating a transnational Yoruba citizenry”
Maxim Bulanov, doctoral student
This article examines the cultural-political activity of African-origin religious organizations in
Cuba, Cabildos, which have been forming since the 1800s. These organizations, led by
community leaders and religious figures, were able to maneuver between racist colonial policies that sought to folklorize and commercialize Yoruba religious traditions, while simultaneously using these public performances to maintain and spread their religious practices.
The author traces the transformation of these performances into state-sponsored folklorization,
where Cabildos adapted their customs to be showcased in cultural events and performances,
allowing for their religious rituals to be practiced publicly in a secular context. Despite this
folklorization, the spiritual and religious essence of these traditions remained intact, helping the
Cabildos resist complete assimilation into state control. The author argues that these
performances served as counter-hegemonic narratives, resisting the structural racism that had
historically marginalized African-descended people in Cuba (Concha-Holmes, 2013, 491).

In contrast, the Karen bamboo and don dances, as described by Heather MacLachlan (2014),
underwent a different transformation within the Karen diaspora communities. Originally
associated with religious and funeral rituals, these dances have lost much of their original
religious meaning over time. In the diaspora, particularly among Karen youth in Fort Wayne,
Indiana, these dances are now primarily used to teach and reinforce ethnic identity rather than
religious devotion. As MacLachlan notes, the bamboo dance, once performed in connection with funeral rites, has become a symbol of Karen-ness, a tool for preserving cultural identity among young Karen refugees who may never have seen their homeland (MacLachlan, 2014)
Whereas Cabildos continued to blend their spiritual significance with public performance, Karen
community leaders the secularization of their dances. The leaders’ primary focus is on fostering
ethnic unity and cultural survival rather than religious practice. The don dance, once tied to
courtship rituals and funerals is now performed to celebrate Karen cultural identity during
community events, reinforcing a shared sense of heritage for displaced people.

Thus, while both Cabildos and Karen dances adapted to public performance under external
pressures, the Cabildos managed to retain their religious significance, along with nurturing the
cultural citizenship (Rosaldo, 2003) helping participants to overcome structural inequalities in specific territories, whereas the Karen dances became detached from their original spiritual
context, now serving as a means of cultural education rather than religious devotion.
The comparison illustrates how cultural practices can evolve differently depending on the
territorial and political circumstances in which the group is situated.

References cited
Concha-Holmes, A. D. 2013. "Cuban Cabildos, Cultural Politics, and Cultivating a Transnational
Yoruba Citizenry." Cultural Anthropology 28 (4): 490–503.
https://doi.org/10.1111/cuan.12016.
MacLachlan, Heather. 2014. “Singing, Dancing, and Identity in the Karen Diaspora.” Asian
Music 45 (2): 58–83.
Rosaldo, Renato. Cultural Citizenship in Island Southeast Asia: Nation and Belonging in the
Hinterlands. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2003.

Made on
Tilda